The Westerwelle Plan
von zeev avrahamiIt is time to say the obvious: After ten years we can come to the conclusion that these two kids, Israel and Palestine, can’t solve their problems on their own. They have been in this sandbox for too long and they have been hitting each other too hard that by now both are almost bleeding to death. It is time for the referee to step in and tell the sides: you must stop. Your bloodshed is staining the entire universe. Maybe you want to consider Chess instead of boxing?
But who can become this referee? I am counting out France and Italy. I mean, look who these people voted to lead their respective countries. I can’t trust them. England? Didn’t they make the mess to begin with? Besides, sometimes I read and see England’s and Spain’s action toward Israel and I think to myself: If Goebbels was around he would probably telegram them to cool off. So, in my opinion, we are left with Germany. I think its schizophrenic case is a perfect balance: its guilt will write off its tendency to support the underdog.
But what should Germany do? If I have learned something about German people it is that they are very calculated with their money. they earn x amount of money and they know exactly how much they will spend on bills, rent, food and vacations. Maybe a few can allow themselves to live above their means, but in general It is a very responsible system, no credit cards to run your dreams on.
So how come Germany (and the EU and Japan) is not accounted for the money it pours into the Palestinian hands? for two decades now the world had invested billions in Palestine, and it seems like nobody seems to care where are this billions are going. It is obvious that Israel carry some of the blame with its restrictions, control of the borders and its horrible bombing of Palestine, but Israel should also be the example. It was built by people who held a rifle in one hand and worked the fields with the other. There are many negative things to say about Israel but no one can take away the miracle of how it built itself, and how it functions as a normal democracy with all the infrastructure in place.
I expect Germany to say: look, we gave you all this money, but we can’t see any infrastructure here, we can’t see any seeding for the roots of building your own country. No welfare system, no education, no functioning healthcare system, no civil servants to serve the people. And then I expect Germany to reach the most humanist conclusion and freeze most of the money it gives to Palestine and invest it in German companies.
It should give these companies huge tax breaks and other encouragements and ask them to open new factories in Palestine. The Palestinians will have work places, the companies will have cheap labor force. I understand that this is not so easy, that, just like in Africa, this idea can run and killed by the local bureaucracies, but isn’t worth a try? didn’t we exhausted all the other great ideas of “let’s sit down and talk” and giving unfulfilled ultimatums?
But why do I call it humanist solution if this is pure economic? because I believe that the people who live in Gaza or Nablus are not different from me or the average citizen in the West. That all they want to have is a decent job, with a decent salary. That just like me they just want to go to work, come back for dinner with the family, sit down on the balcony or with friends in a cafe, have two vacations a year, secure the future of their kids. In my mind, anyone who have job and normal life will tell the extremists: “I pass on heaven and the 70 virgins, you can go to hell”.
Kommentar schreiben
the problem is that these two kids in the sandbox are actually two grown adults that need to be kicked off the playground, and by that I mean a completly new start or beginning….out with the old single minded conservitive politician, and bring out a new generation of open minded
Israelis and Palestinians…..wishful thinking???????????????
shalom
Matthias
Matthias, they are two adults who never grew up.
What you are describing, Zeev, is already a method of development aid. I think one of the problems is, that even with huge tax breaks most German (and not only German) companies have no incentive to build something up in Palestine.
In a country with a destroyed infrastructure, difficulties to export, no safety and military as well as terroristic assaults you destroy money by investing strongly .
At first you have to change the framework, build up an infrastructure, enforce the law and reach a certain level of safety.
So we are back at the beginning, it is a vicious circle…
I like the film night in the museum. Where Larry and the monkey hit each other and Roosevelt asks “who has evolved”. I like to ask this question to my struggling sons to hint there might be a more civilised solution.
Regarding the situation (Well, and the perspectives) in the area of israel and Palestine, I believe that the basic mistake and the cause of the whole conflict lies in the religious beliefs. Not surprising, I guess, but let me explain.
The area has been governed by a lot of organisations, jewish, islamic, and of course the knights of the temple, too. Good thing they don’t get into those fights, too, as they are kind of extinct.
It reminds me of the struggels og Erika Steinbach and her cronies at the ‘Bund der Vertriebenen’ with the countries their fathers (Or, partly, they themselves) once lived in and ruled.
If you actually want to embrace the concept of peace over life-long fights, you have to give up the thought that because you were at a span of time been the owner of some piece of land, you have an everlasting right to own it. Others have owned it before, others will own in future, there never can be an everlasting right.
For the sake of peace, abandon your religious or whatever rights at the land and build a bridge that allows the wounds to heal and the actual people to go and just live their life.
If people can’t do that, they will lock themselves up in their corner and keep on spilling blood (their own and the opponents, including blood of people who want to help both of you).
Might be naive, but in the end, shed the hate and embrace the concept of love.
Schalom, my friends
Claus,
There is only one justified war from my view, a peaceful war without any arms and weapons: the war of open minded, non biased people against religious as it is today. I believe we are the majority.